Na ye chaand hogaa na taare rahenge
Posted on: June 3, 2009
This song from “Shart” (1954) has two versions. Female version is sung by Geeta Dutt and picturised on Shyama. Male version is sung by Hemant Kumar and picturised on Deepak.
It is not advisable to compare the two. Instead, it is advisable to savour both the versions. This song has gone on to become an iconic song. The lyrics of this song must be one of the most well known lyrics that S H Bihari ever wrote. The music was composed by Hemant Kumar and it was just his second movie as a music director. This movie was preceded by “Anandmath” and followed by “Nagin”. That was the kind of music Hemant Kumar was creating those days.
Here are both the versions of this song.
Audio – Geeta Dutt version
Video – Geeta Dutt version
Video – Hemant Kumar version
Video – Hemant Kumar version
Song-Na ye chaand hogaa na taare rahenge (Shart) (1954) Singer-Geeta Dutt/Hemant Kumar, Lyrics-S H Bihari, MD-Hemant Kumar
———————————-
Geeta Dutt version
na ye chaand hogaa na taare rahenge
magar ham hameshaa tumhaare rahenge
na ye chaand hogaa na taare rahenge
magar ham hameshaa tumhaare rahenge
na ye chaand hogaa
nazar dhoondhti jise paa liyaa hai
ummeedon ke phoolon se daaman bharaa hai
ye din hamko sab din se pyaare rahenge
na ye chaand hogaa na taare rahenge
magar ham hameshaa tumhaare rahenge
na ye chaand hogaa
kahoon kyaa mere dil kaa armaan kyaa hai
tumhen har ghadi choomnaa chaahtaa hai
kahaan tak bhalaa ji ko maare rahenge
na ye chaand hogaa na taare rahenge
magar ham hameshaa tumhaare rahenge
na ye chaand hogaa
————————————
Hemant Kumar version
aaa aaa
na ye chaand hogaa, na taare rahenge
magar ham hameshaa, tumhaare rahenge
na ye chaand hogaa, na taare rahenge
magar ham hameshaa, tumhaare rahenge
na ye chaand hogaa…
bichhadkar chale jaayen tumse kahin
to ye naa samajhnaa muhabbat nahin
jahaan bhi rahe ham tumhaare rahenge
na ye chaand hogaa, na taare rahenge
magar ham hameshaa, tumhaare rahenge
na ye chaand hogaa
zamaanaa agar kuchh kahe bhi to kyaa
magar tum na kahnaa hamen bewafaa
tumhaare liye hain tumhaare rahenge
na ye chaand hogaa, na taare rahenge
magar ham hameshaa, tumhaare rahenge
na ye chaand hogaa
ye ho na sitam hamne pahle na jaana
bana bhi na tha jal gaya aashiyaana
kahaan muhabbat ke maare rahenge
na ye chaand hogaa, na taare rahenge
magar ham hameshaa, tumhaare rahenge
na ye chaand hogaa
7 Responses to "Na ye chaand hogaa na taare rahenge"
[…] I have posted two memorable songs from “Shart” (1954) in the past namely Na ye chaand hogaa na taare rahenge (Shart) and Dekho wo chaand chhupke kartaa hai kyaa ishaare (Shart) . This movie had another nice song in […]
LikeLike
October 15, 2011 at 1:37 am
Just no words to express the joy of listening the legendary lyrics, just immortal!
LikeLike
June 24, 2012 at 12:53 pm
What has been posted on this page are the two middle versions of “Na ye chaand hogaa na taare rahenge”. The other two versions are also on YouTube: The first one at http://youtu.be/MtcjfNHY62s from 02:01 to 02:34 of that video clip and the final one at 05:38 to 05:58 in the video clip at http://youtu.be/WzJl_ujI7dg.
LikeLike
October 30, 2012 at 3:08 pm
Brilliant song, and wonderful rendition by both of them Thank you.
LikeLike
Atul’s Song A Day- A choice collection of Hindi Film & Non-Film Songs 
June 3, 2009 at 6:43 am
breathtakingly lovely song.
Thanks for posting both versions, they are both superb!
LikeLike